Hawaii Travel Made Easy Podcast—Hawaii travel tips, Things to do in Hawaii, Hawaii vacation planning

Which Hawaiian Island Should You Visit First? (Take This 3-Minute Quiz) [BONUS EPISODE]

• Marcie Cheung • Episode 66

Share episode

Choosing Your Ideal Hawaiian Island: Oahu vs. Maui, Big Island, and Kauai

In this episode, Marcie from Hawaii Travel Made Easy addresses the common dilemma of choosing between Hawaiian islands for first-time visitors, specifically comparing Oahu and Maui. Marcie explains that there is no single 'best' island, and introduces a framework to help choose the perfect island based on travelers' preferences. She covers the unique characteristics and highlights of the four major islands—Oahu, Maui, Big Island, and Kauai—and offers advice based on planning preferences, desired activities, food scenes, and travel companions. Marcie also discusses her travel consultations and digital guides that provide personalized travel planning to ensure a stress-free Hawaiian vacation.

00:00 Introduction and Common Dilemma
00:54 Overview of the Hawaiian Islands
01:50 Choosing Based on Travel Preferences
02:58 Activities and Experiences
03:35 Food and Dining Options
04:07 Travel Companions and Their Needs
05:14 Summary and Next Steps
06:25 Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Buy my Hawaii guides on my blog or Amazon

Book a Hawaii Travel Consultation

Blog posts related to this podcast

Follow me on Instagram @hawaiitravelwithkids

Join our Patreon Community

Aloha. This is Marcie from Hawaii. Travel Made Easy and today I'm solving a problem that literally fills up my Instagram dms every single week. Yesterday alone, I got the same question three different times. Marcie, it's our first time going to Hawaii and we're stuck between Oahu and Maui. Just tell us which one. I get it. Four major islands and they're all completely different. It just feels like this huge decision. You don't wanna mess up, but I'm gonna tell you something that might actually surprise you. There's no single best First Island. What works perfectly for one person would be totally wrong for someone else. So I'm walking you through the exact framework I use in my travel consultations. Think of it like a quick quiz to match people with their ideal island. It takes about three minutes, and by the end of the episode, you'll know exactly where you should go, and more importantly, you'll feel confident about booking it. Okay, before I walk you through the questions, you need to understand what you're actually choosing between. Oahu is the urban one. You've got Waikiki Beach, Pearl Harbor, incredible restaurants, nightlife, crowds, the whole thing. It's the most developed island, and honestly, that's not a bad thing for first timers. Everything just works easier there. Maui sits right in the middle, beautiful beaches, the road to Hana, fantastic resorts, but way more chill than Oahu. It's not too crowded, not too remote. That's why so many people love it. The big island is where you'll go for adventure, active volcanoes, black sand, beaches, coffee farms, and you can literally drive through multiple climate zones. In one day. It's at least touristy, but you're gonna be in the car a lot and things are more spread out. Kauai is the nature island. Gorgeous scenery everywhere you look, but it's the most remote with the least development. Amazing if you're into hiking and natural beauty. But there are way fewer resort options and activities compared to the other island. Got it. Now here's how to figure out which one matches what you actually want. Okay, so here's what I've learned from doing hundreds of these consultations. It really comes down to four things. Once you think through these, the answer gets pretty obvious. The biggest thing that matters, how you actually feel about planning? Because if you want everything to just be easy, like you show up, you get in an Uber and there are a million restaurant options and booking activities doesn't require a ton of research, Oahu makes that happen. The tourism infrastructure there is so built out that everything's just straightforward. If you don't mind doing some planning, but you still want things to be reasonably convenient without too much hassle, Maui's probably your answer. It's that perfect middle ground. Now, if you're someone who genuinely enjoys the research part of trips and you're totally fine driving a lot, and you actually like the feeling of discovering things, the big island could be perfect, but I'm gonna be real with you. It takes more effort. Kauai is trickier if logistics stress you out, but you're willing to deal with it for absolutely stunning nature. It might work. But honestly, I tell most people to save Hawaii for their second Hawaii trip once they understand how island travel works. The next thing, and this is huge, what do you actually want to do when you're there? Picture your ideal day in Hawaii. Are you thinking mostly beach time with maybe one excursion? Then you might want Maui or Oahu. Both have incredible easy to access beaches. If you're imagining something more like half beach days, half adventure. Maui winds hands down, you get those beaches plus Haleakala, the road to Hana. Amazing snorkeling. It's got that perfect mix. But if you're more excited about volcanoes and dramatic landscapes than you are about lounging on the beach, like adventure is the main thing in beaches. Secondary, that's the big island calling your name. Then there's the food situation, which matters more than people think. Do you want options? Like you wanna try a different restaurant every single night, hit up food trucks, check out the farmer's markets, and maybe go out after dinner? That's Oahu. The food scene there is incredible. Maui's got really good restaurants, especially at the resorts, plus some amazing local spots. You won't have endless choices, but you'll have plenty of excellent ones. The Big Island is more about those authentic local experiences. There are fewer restaurants overall, but the ones that are there tend to be more meaningful and connected to the actual culture. And Kauai has some amazing food options, and then who you're traveling with changes everything bringing the kids. Oahu has the most family friendly setup, safe beaches, activities for different ages, all the conveniences. My Oahu guide covers all these specific family spots. Is this a romantic getaway? Maui's resort areas are literally designed for couples. Intimate beaches, sunset dinners, that whole vibe. Multi-generational trip with grandparents and teenagers who want completely different things. Oahu, again, there's genuinely something for everyone from easy beach, access for grandparents to enough activities to keep teenagers from complaining if it's you and your adventurous friends, big island all the way. So here's how this usually shakes out when people work through these questions. Easy logistics. Lots of beach time. Good dining. You're going to Oahu, you'll love Waikiki. And how convenient everything is. Some planning involved, a mix, a beach and adventure. Good food without it being overwhelming. Maui is your answer. If you like planning, you want more adventure than beach and you care about authentic experiences, book the Big Island. Now, what happens in my consultations all the time is people figuring out their island from thinking through this stuff, but then they get stuck on the next level. Like, okay, I know I want Maui, but should I stay in Wailea or Ka'anapali, how many days do I actually need? What about a rental car? That's where personalized planning makes a huge difference. These questions get you to the right island, but all the specifics, your actual budget, your travel dates, your group's dynamics, the things you absolutely have to do, that's what makes or breaks the trip. If you work through these questions and know where you're going, amazing. Start planning. If you're still torn between two islands or you know your island, but you're overwhelmed by everything else, you need to figure out, that's exactly what my travel consultations are for. We spend an hour going deep into your specific situation, your travel style, your timeline, and we create a personalized plan that takes all the stress out of it. I also have digital travel guides for each island that walk you through where to stay, what to do, and how to plan your days. If you've picked your island and want the DIY approach with step-by-step guidance, those guides are perfect. Everything's at Hawaii. Travel with kids.com. Click Hawaii Travel Consultant if you want personalized help or Hawaii Travel Guides, if you wanna do it yourself with detailed guidance. Look, every Hawaiian Island is incredible. There's genuinely no wrong choice here. You just want the one that matches what you're actually looking for. I hope working through these questions helped you figure it out. If you use this to pick your island, send me a DM on Instagram at Hawaii, travel with kids, and tell me which one won and why. I love hearing how people make this decision. Until next time, keep dreaming of those turquoise waters. Your perfect Hawaii vacation is totally doable. Aloha.